Resolved, the
House of _____ concurring,
That the 75
th
General Convention of the Episcopal Church adopt the following statement as a
response to the Instruments of Unity of the Anglican Communion:
Our
History
The
Protestant Episcopal Church in the United States
of America, otherwise known as the Episcopal
Church, began in the aftermath of a bloody revolution against
England. Because
the Church of England was an established Church and because it still swears
loyalty to the Crown, the “ecclesiastical independence” of this Church from the
Church of England was and is necessary. (The Preface of the Book of Common
Prayer, 1789, p. 10, The Book of Common Prayer, 1979) Once the United States
became independent from England “the different religious denominations of
Christians in these States were left at full and equal liberty to model and
organize their respective Churches, and forms of worship, and discipline, in
such manner as they might judge most convenient for their future prosperity;
consistently with the constitution and laws of this country.” (The Preface etc.) However, from that time until the present
“this Church is far from intending to depart from the Church of England in an
essential point of doctrine, discipline, or worship; or further than local
circumstances require.” (The Preface, etc.) Further,
“It is
also recognized and affirmed that the threefold ministry is not the exclusive
property of this portion of Christ’s catholic Church,
but is a gift from God for the nurture of his people and the proclamation of his
Gospel everywhere. Accordingly, the manner of ordaining in this Church is to be
such as has been, and is, most generally recognized by Christian people as
suitable for the conferring of the sacred orders of bishop, priest, and deacon.”
(Preface to the Ordination Rites, The Book of Common Prayer, p.
510)
Why We Consented to New
Hampshire’s Election in 2003
It is the on the
question of “an essential point of doctrine, discipline, or worship” that the
Episcopal Church and some members of the Anglican Communion have their current
disagreement. The question is, “Does the ordination and consecration to the
episcopate of a person of homosexual orientation who is living in a monogamous
faithful relationship with a person of the same sex represent a departure from
the Church of England in an essential point of doctrine, discipline or worship?”
It is the belief of the Episcopal Church that it does not.
We look first to
the Chicago-Lambeth Quadrilateral, Resolution 11
adopted by the Lambeth Conference of 1888. The
Episcopal Church accepts:
The Holy Scriptures of the Old
and New Testaments, as “containing all things necessary to salvation,” and as
being the rule and ultimate standard of faith.
The
Apostles’ Creed, as the Baptismal Symbol; and the Nicene Creed, as the
sufficient statement of the Christian faith.
The two Sacraments
ordained by Christ Himself—Baptism and the Supper of the Lord—ministered with
unfailing use of Christ’s words of institution, and of the elements ordained by
Him.
The Historic Episcopate, locally adapted in the
methods of its administration to the varying needs of the nations and peoples
called of God into the Unity of His Church.
(The Book of Common Prayer, 1979,
p. 87)
We look also to the
Thirty-nine Articles which were adopted by the General Convention of this Church
in 1801.
In particular we look to Article XXV-Of the Sacraments, which states
in part, “Those five commonly called Sacraments, that is to say, Confirmation,
Penance, Orders, Matrimony, and Extreme Unction, are not to be counted for
Sacraments of the Gospel, being such as have grown partly of the corrupt
following of the Apostles, partly are states of life allowed in the Scriptures;
but yet have not like nature of the Sacraments with Baptism, and the Lord’s
Supper, for that they have not any visible sign or ceremony ordained of God.”
(The Book of Common Prayer, 1979, p. 872)
We look also to Article XXXIV-Of
the Traditions of the Church, which states in part, “It is not necessary that
Traditions and Ceremonies be in all places one, or utterly like; for at all
times they have been divers, and may be changed according to the diversity of
countries, times, and men’s manners, so that nothing be ordained against God’s
Word….Every particular or national Church hath authority to ordain, change, and
abolish, Ceremonies or Rites of the Church ordained only by man’s authority, so
that all things be done to edifying.” (The Book of Common Prayer, 1979, p.
874)
These Articles lead us to understand that among those commonly called
Sacraments, the Sacraments of Orders and Matrimony are not sacraments of the
Gospel and any visible signs or ceremonies of those Sacraments are ordained only
by human authority. Therefore any national Church, including the Episcopal
Church, has authority to ordain, change, or abolish the ceremonies or rites of
these Sacraments, so long as nothing be ordained
against God’s Word.
The precise point of disagreement within the Anglican
Communion has to do with the interpretation of Holy Scripture, and in
particular, the New Testament. The Episcopal Church believes Holy Scripture is
the rule and ultimate standard of faith, and contains all things necessary to
salvation. The Episcopal Church believes that the New Testament teaches that
certain kinds of sexual behavior are sinful. These behaviors are sinful whether
practiced by homosexuals or heterosexuals. The Episcopal Church believes that
faithful, monogamous, and mutually consensual relations between persons of the
same sex, with the intention that these relations be life long, are not
addressed in the New Testament, are not condemned by it, and are consistent with
a Biblical sexual ethic that requires fidelity to God and one’s beloved. The Episcopal Church considers such
behavior to be a wholesome example for the Church. Further, the Episcopal Church
supports the full inclusion of homosexual persons who are wholesome examples at
all levels of the Anglican Communion.
Our Regret and Repentance
It
is apparent that this interpretation of Scripture is not held by the majority of
those who have participated and voted within the various Instruments of Unity;
the current Archbishop of Canterbury, the most recent Lambeth Conference, the recent Primates meetings, and the
most recent Anglican Consultative Council. It is also apparent that in
confirming the election of the Bishop of New Hampshire, the Episcopal Church has
breached the constraints of the bonds of affection held between it and other
members of the Anglican Communion. The Episcopal Church also holds that the
responses by the Instruments of Unity to our actions have breached the
constraints of the bonds of affection between us, particularly those bonds
between all homosexual members of the Anglican Communion and those who hold
positions of authority within the Anglican Communion. The Episcopal Church
acknowledges our right as an autonomous Province within the Anglican Communion
to take this action. Yet, we offer our own regret for the pain that others have
experienced with respect to our actions at the General Convention of 2003 and we
offer our sincerest apology and repentance for having breached the bonds of
affection in the Anglican Communion by any failure to consult adequately with
our Anglican partners before taking these actions.
The
Episcopal Church regrets the extent to which we have, by action and inaction,
contributed to strains on communion and caused deep offense to many faithful
Anglican Christians as we consented to the consecration of a bishop living
openly in a same-gender union. Accordingly, we urge nominating committees,
electing conventions, Standing Committees, and bishops with jurisdiction to
observe a moratorium by seriously considering the possibility of refraining from
the nomination, election, consent to, and consecration of persons to be bishops
who are living openly in a same-gender union during this triennium, until the
General Convention of 2009.
The
Episcopal Church affirms the need to maintain a breadth of private responses to
situations of individual pastoral care for gay and lesbian Christians in this
Church. We respond to the Windsor Report in its exhortation to bishops of the
Anglican Communion to honor the Primates’ Pastoral Letter of May 2003 by
requesting that bishops observe a period of moratorium by not proceeding to
authorize diocesan-wide Rites of Blessing for same-sex unions during this
triennium, until the General Convention of 2009.
In
suggesting these moratoria we acknowledge not only the pain and injustice these
moratoria inflict on homosexual persons who are among the faithful of this
Church. We also acknowledge that the communal and sacramental life within the
Episcopal Church will be impaired, and that the Episcopal Church will be
depriving its episcopate of dynamic and holy leadership. By depriving the
episcopate of this Church we also believe that the Lambeth Conference and thus the totality of the Instruments
of Unity will also be deprived of persons whose gifts would build up the whole
Body of Christ within the Anglican Communion. By imposing these moratoria the
Episcopal Church believes the whole Anglican Communion will suffer. To be clear,
the Episcopal Church reaffirms that gay and lesbian persons are by Baptism full
members of the Body of Christ and of the Episcopal Church as “children of God
who have a full and equal claim with all other persons upon the love,
acceptance, and pastoral concern and care of the Church” (GC 1976-A069); and we
reiterate our apology “on behalf of the Episcopal Church to its members who are
gay or lesbian, and to lesbians and gay men outside the Church, for years of
rejection and maltreatment by the Church,” and recommit to “seek amendment of
our life together as we ask God’s help in sharing the Good News with all people”
(GC1997-D011); and we reiterate that “our baptism into Jesus Christ is
inseparable from our communion with one another, and we commit ourselves to that
communion despite our diversity of opinion and, among dioceses, a diversity of
pastoral practice with the gay men and lesbians among us (GC2003–C051). ”
Our Future
In
suggesting these moratoria the Episcopal Church signifies its deep longing to
remain fully present at the Anglican table. During this time of moratoria we
hope to be advocates for homosexuals throughout the Anglican Communion. It is
the expectation of the Episcopal Church that having imposed these moratoria our
Primate, Bishops (including the Bishop of New Hampshire), and members of the
Anglican Consultative Council we will once again be invited and allowed to fully
participate in the Primates meetings, the Lambeth
Conference, and the Anglican Consultative Council. Whether all participants will
choose to accept their invitations, particularly those bishops who are asked to
absent themselves from these bodies in the Windsor Report, will depend on the
conscience of each person.
Should our Primate, our bishops with jurisdiction,
and our delegates to the Anglican Consultative Council not be invited or allowed
full participation in these bodies, this General Convention authorizes the
Executive Council of the Episcopal Church to reconsider, amend, or end these
moratoria.
The
Episcopal Church commits to the ongoing “Windsor
Process,” a process of discernment as to the nature and unity of the Church, as
we pursue a common life of dialogue, listening, and growth, formed and informed
by the Baptismal Covenant and Eucharistic fellowship; and it urges all members
of this church to commit themselves to the call of communion and interdependent
life; and it commends the steps taken by the Anglican Communion Office in
beginning a formal “Listening Process” across the Communion, as commended by
resolution I.10 of the 1998 Lambeth Conference; and it
commends for further study and as part of the continued Listening Process the
document To Set our Hope on Christ, prepared for the 13th Meeting of the
Anglican Consultative Council by the Office of the Presiding Bishop; and it
expresses its gratitude to the women of the Anglican Consultative Council’s
Delegation to the United Nations Consultation on the Status of Women for
providing a model of dialogue and engagement on issues of concern to all; and
asks that this model be considered for implementation in the Windsor and
Listening processes across the Anglican Communion; and we commend the report
“One Baptism, One Hope in God’s Call” of the Special Commission on the Episcopal
Church and the Anglican Communion as a resource in the Windsor and Listening
processes.
The
Episcopal Church notes with alarm the practice of bishops crossing diocesan
boundaries without permission of the diocesan, in direct contradiction to the
Windsor Report. The Episcopal Church affirms the centrality of effective and
appropriate pastoral care for all members of this church and all who come
seeking the aid of this church. The
Episcopal Church commits to the ongoing engagement of and sensitive response to
the request and need of all the people of God – in particular, but not
exclusively, those who agree and those who disagree with the actions of this
body, those who feel isolated thereby, and gay and lesbian persons within and
without this Church. The Episcopal Church recognizes the agonizing position of
those who do not feel able to receive appropriate pastoral care from their own
bishops, and urges the members of the House of Bishops to seek the highest
degree of communion and reconciliation within their own dioceses, using when
necessary the Delegated Episcopal Pastoral Oversight (DEPO) process detailed in
the March 2004 statement of the House of Bishops, “Caring for All the Churches.”
The Episcopal Church urges continued attention to the proper maintenance of
historic diocesan boundaries and the authority of the diocesan bishop.
It
is the intention of the Episcopal Church to remain “a constituent member of the
Anglican Communion; a fellowship within Christ’s One, Holy, Catholic and
Apostolic Church of those duly constituted Dioceses, Provinces, and regional
Churches in Communion with the See of Canterbury, upholding and propagating the
historic Faith and Order as set forth in the Book of Common Prayer.” (The
Preamble of the Constitution of the Episcopal Church) We continue to pray for
our brothers and sisters within the Anglican Communion on a daily basis through
the Anglican Cycle Prayer. We continue our Companion Diocese relations. We
continue to support the United Nations Millennium Development Goals which will
positively affect millions of Anglicans. And we pray that all of our actions
will help the bonds of affection within our Communion to be strengthened and
healed, in order that Christ’s Church may be One, even as Christ with our
Creator and the Holy Spirit are One.